The biggest question facing the Patriots this offseason, the biggest offseason question in the history of the franchise, remains whether or not Tom Brady will be back.
We know he's a free agent. We know that for the first time in his career he has the ability to listen to offers from other teams across the NFL. We know he wants to play.
We also know there's no other pending Patriots free agent who'll have a bigger say on Patriots wins and losses for the 2020 season. Despite the way the season ended for him — numbers down, games against the Dolphins and Bengals pocked with inexplicably inaccurate throws — he still has the ability to execute at a high level when healthy.
That makes locking Brady in for another year at a reasonable price — the definition of "reasonable" could end up determining his whereabouts next season — a priority for this offseason, in our view.
But what about everyone else? The Patriots have plenty of contributing players set to hit the market this offseason.
Here's how we'd rank 'em, in order of ascending importance...
New England Patriots
No. 14: Marshall Newhouse
Signed off the street and smart enough to be able to pick up the Patriots offense on the fly, Newhouse ended up starting eight games for the team with Isaiah Wynn out. But he graded out as one of the worst tackles in the league and had difficulty handling the athletic requirements of the position in today's NFL.
The Patriots have Yodny Cajuste in the pipeline — drafted in the third round last spring — who could end up playing in a reserve role in 2020. This also looks like a strong draft class for offensive tackles.
No. 13: Nick Folk
Stephen Gostkowski is under contract through next season. He's scheduled to make $3.5 million in base salary and count $5.3 million against the cap. Releasing him would free up almost $4 million.
That's nothing to sneeze at, but if he's healthy, it's hard to see Bill Belichick choosing Nick Folk over the franchise's leading scorer. Folk impressed by making 14 of his 17 field goal attempts and all 12 of his extra-point tries.
No. 12: James Ferentz
The veteran interior offensive lineman has hung around New England since 2017 thanks to his ability to understand the system and play three different positions. He ranks as a low-priority option here, though, because it should be a relatively easy to keep him around if the Patriots wanted to.
The healthy return of Hjalte Froholdt and free-agent decisions on Joe Thuney and Ted Karras could impact how willing the Patriots are to keep things going with Ferentz, who played 203 snaps this year.
No. 11: Shilique Calhoun
Calhoun fit the Patriots profile as a long and athletic outside linebacker in the 3-4 scheme that became their go-to this year. In his only season with the team, he ended up playing 268 snaps and saw his playing time reduced defensively as the year went along. After playing 55 snaps in Week 1, he never cracked the 30-snap mark again. He played 22 snaps defensively in the team's final three must-win games of the year, and ended the season with 16 total quarterback pressures.
One of the team's top special-teamers — he played 235 snaps in the kicking game — Calhoun could end up returning in a similar role. And if the Patriots feel as though they might lose Kyle Van Noy to free agency, then perhaps Calhoun could come back and help fill in more defensively.
No. 10: Nate Ebner
A core special-teamer since his arrival in 2012, Ebner reprised that role again in 2019. He saw 333 snaps in the kicking game and served as the personal protector on the punt team.
He's among Bill Belichick's most trusted special-teams options, becoming somewhat of a coach-on-the-field type along with Matthew Slater. He blocked a punt against the Chiefs and still appears to have plenty of good football left in him. It'd come as little surprise if he ended up back in New England.
No. 9: Ted Karras
Thrust into the center's role with David Andrews out, Karras started all but one game this season. He was durable and on top of the system to the point that he was able to win the job over early-season acquisition Russell Bodine.
The Patriots missed having their regular starter this season — Andrews' athleticism allowed the team to do things they couldn't with another player in there — but if Andrews is able to return to his regular workload in 2020, then having Karras back in the mix as the do-it-all interior backup would make plenty of sense for the Patriots.
No. 8: Elandon Roberts
Roberts was not a starting-caliber linebacker for the Patriots, but he was named a captain for the first time prior to the season. Why? Part of the reason became apparent as the 2019 year went on and he took on the role of the team's top fullback.
He might not have been thrilled to be considered an offensive player — he played more offensive snaps than defensive snaps in the team's final three games — but he provided a level of toughness the offense needed.
Fullback shouldn't be in his future, but if the Patriots wanted him back as a special-teamer and fill-in linebacker then there could be a place for him on the roster. Belichick values having a certain toughness quotient in his locker room, and there are few people on the team who have a hankering for contact the way Roberts does.
No. 7: Phillip Dorsett
Dorsett's season was largely quiet, and as the season went on he and Tom Brady appeared to be on different pages. Still, he proved throughout the course of 2018 that if he's handed the role of a No. 4 wideout he can bring value to the team.
That might be where he slots in for 2020 if he were to return as Julian Edelman, N'Keal Harry and Mohamed Sanu are all under contract next season. If the Patriots view Jakobi Meyers as the better option as a No. 4, then Dorsett's time with the team might be over.
No. 6: Danny Shelton
In Belichick's 3-4 defense, he needed a nose tackle. It looked like he'd signed one in Mike Pennel before the start of the season, but Danny Shelton claimed the job with a strong training camp and Pennel was released. He continued that effort through the regular season and was one of the team's most consistent front-seven players in 2019, starting every game but two.
Unfortunately for the Patriots, Shelton was inked to just a one-year deal last offseason. Now if there's a team looking for a big-body to play in the middle of their defensive line, Shelton could end up being one of the top options in free agency.
No. 5: Matthew Slater
The 34-year-old proved that he can still hit top speed and find the football with the best of them.
The captain of one of the league's top special-teams units over the last several years, Slater earned his fifth first-team All-Pro nod for his performance in 2019. As important as Slater has been to the team's kicking-game for the last decade, he's also critical to maintaining the culture behind the scenes.
One of the last links — along with Tom Brady and Stephen Gostkowski — to an era in New England that included players like Mike Vrabel, Tedy Bruschi and Rodney Harrison, one would think that Belichick would do all he can to keep Slater around through the end of his playing days. And maybe beyond.
No. 4: Jamie Collins
One of the team's top players through the first six weeks of the season — he had an argument as the best player on the league's best defense — Collins' play dipped as the season went along.
According to Pro Football Focus, he had four games with grades exceeding 90.0 through Week 6. He had one game exceeding 70.0 the rest of the way and finished the year with his worst grade of the season (29.9) against the Titans and their power running game.
In a scheme that allows him to blitz and drop into zones, Collins can be a game-changer, but he's not the run-thumper the Patriots often want at the second level. Whether or not he returns will likely depend on how the Patriots — and any potential suitors — view the disparity in his play between the early part of the season and later.
No. 3: Kyle Van Noy
The Patriots don't tend to pay edge defenders about to make big-time money in free agency. They didn't do it with Chandler Jones. They didn't do it with Trey Flowers.
Van Noy doesn't reach the level that those two did, but odds are — particularly with Patriots-related coaching staffs all over the NFL — that there will be another team that values Van Noy's abilities more than New England does.
If Belichick views Chase Winovich as someone who can play more than just third down as he gets into the second year of his professional career and beyond, then he may be prepared to bid Van Noy adieu after a stay that included three Super Bowl appearances and two Lombardi Trophies.
No. 2: Joe Thuney
The team's quarterback decision could end up determining how things play out with Thuney.
If Brady is back at a dollar amount that might prevent many other big-money signings, then Thuney could be gone. He ended up having the sixth-best grade of any guard — right or left — in the NFL, according to PFF. He was third in pass-blocking grade.
In a league where interior pass-rushers are among the game's most disruptive players, making sure quarterbacks are protected inside is as important as ever. Thuney's one of the best in football when it comes to that, and smack in the middle of his prime. There's a chance he ends up the highest-paid guard in the league.
If the Patriots free up money by going with an inexpensive quarterback, then maybe Thuney — who's played over 99 percent of the team's snaps since entering the league in 2016 — could be back. Not a bad player, a young core piece, around which to build. Shaq Mason is paid as a top-25 interior lineman based on average annual value.
Would that prevent the Patriots from shelling out big money for Thuney?
No. 1: Devin McCourty
McCourty toyed with the idea of retirement ahead of last year's Super Bowl, but he's made it very clear that he's looking to play in 2020.
Will it be with the team that drafted him in the first round in 2010? If the Patriots want to maintain one of the best defenses in football, they should do what they can to get him back on a deal that keeps him from finishing out his career elsewhere.
The strength of this year's group was in the secondary due in large part to the elite play they received from Stephon Gilmore. But McCourty ended up with five picks himself and served as the secondary's nerve center.
On a defense that changes plans from drive to drive and snap to snap — a defense that's reliant on a young coaching staff — McCourty brought immense value in 2019. He'd do the same in 2020, and it likely wouldn't cost a huge sum over many years the same way it would with someone like Thuney.
Maintaining a level of consistency for the league's No. 1 defense might be their best bet at remaining competitive in the AFC in the short term, and reuniting with McCourty is the simplest way to get started in that direction.